Book a call

Contact Info

Our Location

Melbourne, Victoria 3000

Common Law

Home Services Common Law
DORSiA — Legal Management

Common Law

Common law matters don't come with a scheme's built-in scale to lean on — every item of cost has to be justified on ordinary principle rather than slotted into a prescribed rate. That makes them more exposed to challenge, not less, because there's no shorthand for 'the scale allows it.' The reasoning has to stand on its own.

DORSiA costs common law matters the way they need to be costed: against the specific facts of the file, the work actually undertaken, and what's reasonable and proportionate for a matter of that nature. That's a slower process than applying a scale rate, and it's the only one that produces a bill able to withstand scrutiny."

Where a common law matter is contested — on assessment, in negotiation with the paying party, or internally within the firm — the quality of the original costing decision is usually what determines how that dispute resolves. Getting it right the first time is cheaper than defending it later.

The cost approach involves

Costing a common law matter starts with understanding what actually happened in the file — not just the outcome, but the work that produced it. That means:

  • Establishing the correct basis for recovery given the matter type and how it resolved
  • Reviewing the file in full to identify what work was reasonably and necessarily undertaken
  • Applying the relevant case law and principles that govern what's recoverable at common law, rather than a fixed scale
  • Drafting the bill so each item is defensible on its own terms, not reliant on a scale reference to justify it
  • Stress-testing the bill against how a costs assessor or the paying party is likely to challenge it, before it's sent

Where common law costing gets contested

The areas that draw the most scrutiny in common law costing are rarely the big-ticket items — they're the ones that look routine but lack clear justification on the file. Time entries without a clear connection to work product. Disbursements that aren't adequately evidenced. Steps taken that, viewed in hindsight, look more cautious than necessary. None of these are fatal on their own, but stacked together they're what turns a straightforward bill into a contested one.

The other recurring issue is proportionality — costs that are technically justifiable but disproportionate to what was actually at stake in the matter. Courts and assessors look at this closely in common law matters precisely because there's no scale to point to as a ceiling. Costing with that scrutiny in mind from the outset avoids having to defend it after the fact.

How we approach common law costing

Every common law file is read before it's costed — not summarised from a covering note, but read. That's what surfaces the detail that actually determines the bill: the specific steps taken, why they were taken, and whether the file itself supports the reasoning behind each one.

From there, the bill is drafted to hold up under the standard it will actually be tested against — indemnity, standard, or whatever basis applies — rather than drafted generically and adjusted later. Where a matter is likely to be contested, that's flagged early, and the bill is prepared with that dispute already in mind rather than reacting to it once it's raised.

Call To Action

“Start with the real issue"

Tell us what's at stake, what's changed, and what decision needs to be made. You don't need a proposal deck or a discovery call to find out if this works. Send a file. We'll show you.